GRAND RAPIDS, MICH.

Incoming GRPS Superintendent Was Named in Federal Discrimination Lawsuit

A federal lawsuit filed against incoming Grand Rapids Public Schools Superintendent Allison Tingwall alleged that she was among several education officials who engaged in racial and religious discrimination while hiring a Chicago school district principal.

The Grand Rapids Board of Education in October approved Tingwall in an 8-1 vote. She will succeed current Superintendent Leadriane Roby, who oversaw declining enrollment, a massive deficit, and poor student performance in math and English.

Tingwall was among several education officials from across Chicago Public Schools (CPS) who were named in a lawsuit by Abdul Muhammad, a former interim principal at Lindblom Math and Science Academy in Chicago.

Muhammad, a Black Muslim and member of the Nation of Islam, claimed he was wrongfully denied a four-year principal contract and instead given the job in an interim capacity due to his race and religion. He had worked for CPS for more than 25 years before applying to lead Lindblom in 2022, according to a March legal filing.

When Muhammad was first selected for the Lindblom principal job in 2022, CPS officials allegedly attempted to stall instead of naming him to the role.

Devon LaRosa, chief of one of CPS’s 17 school networks, allegedly recommended finding additional applicants for the principal job. Another official, Kishasha Williams-Ford, seconded that call and urged the council to delay its selection, the document claims.

Tingwall, then-CPS executive director of principal quality, sent Muhammad a letter in August informing him that he would not immediately receive the four-year contract. Another letter from Chief of Schools Felicia Sanders said Muhammad’s contract was being reevaluated in the wake of new information concerning his transition into the job. 

Muhammad alleged he was never told what that information was. He was later removed from the principal job in March 2023.

The lawsuit also describes July 2022 text messages involving Lindblom school clerk Isaias Herrera, who claimed an unidentified informant had raised concerns about Muhammad’s membership in the Nation of Islam. Herrera relayed a claim that Muhammad would give people who did not “look or act like him” a difficult time, according to the ruling.

The messages also contained derogatory claims about the Nation of Islam’s attitudes toward Jewish people, white people, and gay people.

Muhammad alleged the unidentified informant was either LaRosa or Sanders, both of whom were involved in his selection process.

A federal judge found the messages supported a plausible inference that Muhammad’s religion influenced the Board’s decision not to award him the contract. The judge also cited Muhammad’s allegations that his two white predecessors had not faced the same unusual selection process, contract denial or early removal.

Muhammad further alleged Chicago officials used unfounded investigations to justify removing him from the position.

Another investigation examined alleged failures to follow reporting procedures involving sexual misconduct at the school. Muhammad maintained that investigators focused on him despite efforts he made to ensure staff followed the required procedures.

In a March ruling, the federal judge allowed Muhammad’s racial and religious discrimination claims against the Chicago Board of Education to proceed under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. 

A federal judge dismissed the claims against Tingwall in March 2026 but allowed discrimination claims against the Chicago Board of Education and four other officials to proceed. The ruling did not establish whether discrimination occurred. 

Tingwall currently oversees principal recruitment and development across more than 520 Chicago public schools. She previously served as principal of Curie Metropolitan High School, where district officials credit her with improvements in student discipline and academic participation.

In announcing her selection, Tingwall said she remained committed to providing quality public education regardless of the demographics of her students.

“Throughout my career, I have remained committed to ensuring that every student has access to a high-quality public education, regardless of race or background,” Tingwall wrote in a statement. “I look forward to working alongside scholars, families, staff, and community partners to build on the district’s strengths and expand opportunities for all learners.” 

Write to hello@grherald.com